Market researchAll setsMy Cards

Ninetales [Black Flame] #12

Base Set
Card Number #12
Recently discovered misprint/variant in early Unlimited prints of Ninetales in Feb 2020. The shadowing is darker, black flame surrounds Ninetales, and card color may be darker overall. This early unlimited print features the same black flame art as seen in the 1st Edition and Shadowless prints. Future unlimited prints of this card removed the black flame. Source: https://www.cgccomics.com/news/article/8861/pokemon-ninetales-variant/
Ungraded
€34.43
 
Grade 9
€309.86
 
PSA 10
–
 

Ninetales [Black Flame] #12 price guide

Current sold value for every grade.
Ungraded€34.43
Grade 1€53.39
Grade 2€28.48
Grade 3€31.15
Grade 4€36.49
Grade 5€54.90
Grade 6€96.79
Grade 7€102.35
Grade 8€157.50
Grade 9€309.86
Grade 9.5€340.88
CGC 10€667.53
CGC 10 Pristine€1,959

Recent sales

Individual completed sales, newest first (Ungraded).
9 Oct 2026Pokemon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Holofoil BLACK FLAME Variant Moderate Play!eBay€26.70
27 Sept 2026Pokemon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Holo foil BLACK FLAME variant Moderate PlayeBay€33.82
19 Sept 2026Pokemon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare WOTC 1999 12/102eBay€33.82
16 Sept 2026Pokemon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare WOTC 1999 12/102eBay€40.94
14 Sept 2026Pokemon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Holofoil BLACK FLAME Variant Moderate Play! 12/102eBay€34.71
6 Sept 2026Ninetales (Black Flame) 12/102 Holo Base Set Unlimited Pokemon MP 12/102eBay€35.59
6 Sept 2026Pokemon Card: Ninetales HOLO 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Rare! GDeBay€38.26
6 Aug 2026Pokemon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare WOTC 1999 12/102eBay€33.82
30 Jun 2026Pokemon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare WOTC 1999 12/102eBay€40.04
28 Jun 2026Pokemon BLACK FLAME Ninetales Base Set 12/102 Holo Rare Shadowless Vulpix 68/102 12/102eBay€52.51
11 Jun 2026Ninetales - Black Flame Shadowless Holo 12/102 Base Set Pokemon TCG MP/LP 012/102eBay€39.16
7 Jun 20261999 Pokémon Game Ninetales-Holo 012/102eBay€87.22
3 Jun 2026Pokémon Ninetales 12/102 Holo Base Set (Shadowless / Black Flame) HP 012/102eBay€22.24
3 Jun 2026Black Flame Ninetales 012/102 Pokemon Base Set Holographic 012/102eBay€35.60
1 Jun 2026Pokémon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Black Flame Base Set Holo Rare WoTC 12/102 012/102eBay€22.24
31 May 2026Pokemon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare WOTC 1999 012/102eBay€140.18
23 May 2026Pokémon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Holo Rare Black Flame 012/102eBay€75.65
22 May 2026Pokémon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Black Flame Base Set Holo Rare WoTC Wizards Mp 12/102eBay€15.99
19 May 2026Pokémon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Black Flame Base Set Holo Rare WoTC 12/102eBay€33.47
19 May 2026Pokémon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Holo Rare Black Flame LP + NM - 012/102eBay€75.65
18 May 2026Pokémon Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Holo Rare 80 HP Black Flame 012/102eBay€22.25
8 May 2026Ninetales 12/102 Base Set Shadowless Black Flame Holo Rare Pokemon Card WOTC 012/102eBay€20.03
4 May 2026Ninetales 12/102 Holo Rare Base Set Shadowless Pokemon Card 1999 Black Flame 012/102eBay€35.20
29 Apr 2026Ninetales - 12/102 Base Set Shadowless BLACK FLAME Holo Rare Pokemon - LPeBay€53.40
28 Apr 2026Pokémon TCG Ninetales 12/102 Black Flame Base Set Holo Rare WoTC 12/102eBay€17.36

How much is Ninetales [Black Flame] #12 (Base Set) worth?

Right now an ungraded copy of Ninetales [Black Flame] #12 from Base Set sells for about €34.43 and a PSA 9 for about €309.86. These values are based on 89 recent completed sales, the latest on 9 Oct 2026. Prices are converted from US dollars to euros and updated every few hours.

More Base Set card prices

The most valuable cards in this set. See all Base Set prices →

Charizard [1st Edition] #4

Base Set
Ungraded€9,139PSA 10€297,666

Charizard #4

Base Set
Ungraded€274.62PSA 10€10,953

Machamp [1st Edition] #8

Base Set
Ungraded€14.23PSA 10€5,047

Mewtwo #10

Base Set
Ungraded€27.35PSA 10€4,159

Blastoise #2

Base Set
Ungraded€93.42PSA 10€7,687

Charizard [Shadowless] #4

Base Set
Ungraded€849.17PSA 10€22,080

Pikachu #58

Base Set
Ungraded€3.30PSA 10€480.62

Venusaur #15

Base Set
Ungraded€59.86PSA 10€4,175

Gyarados #6

Base Set
Ungraded€15.87PSA 10€2,559

Pikachu [1st Edition] #58

Base Set
Ungraded€169.11PSA 10€5,498

Blastoise [1st Edition] #2

Base Set
Ungraded€990.17PSA 10€17,692

Booster Box [1st Edition]

Base Set
Ungraded€5,686PSA 10–